Tahj Bell was born and raised in Bermuda before coming to the United States to further his soccer career. Bell was a NEPSAC standout as a goalkeeper, enabling him to move up the ranks quickly. In August of 2013, Tahj Bell made his professional debut with Hitchin Town, a semi-professional soccer club in England. Tahj Bell made 47 appearances for Hitchin Town before leaving the club in 2015. Bell also made two appearances for the Bermuda National Team, debuting in November of 2011 against Barbados in a World Cup Qualification match.